Waters Tribunal

The Tribunal of Inquiry into the Alleged Assault on John Waters was established to investigate allegations that John Waters was assaulted by police officers on December 7, 1957, in Thurso, Scotland. The inquiry aimed to examine the actions taken by the Caithness Police in connection with the incident. This tribunal was set up under the Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Act, 1921, and was chaired by one of Her Majesty's Scottish judges.

John Waters, a young man from Thurso, claimed that he was physically assaulted by police officers while in custody. The allegations raised serious concerns about police misconduct and the treatment of detainees. The tribunal's primary objective was to investigate these claims thoroughly, determine the facts, and recommend any necessary actions to prevent similar incidents in the future.

The inquiry involved gathering testimonies from key witnesses, including John Waters, police officers, medical professionals, and other relevant individuals. The tribunal examined various aspects of the incident, such as the circumstances leading up to John Waters' arrest, his treatment while in custody, and the actions taken by the police officers involved.

One of the main findings of the inquiry was that there were discrepancies in the accounts provided by the police officers and John Waters. The tribunal found evidence of procedural failures and inconsistencies in the handling of detainees by the Caithness Police. The inquiry also highlighted the need for better training and supervision of police officers to ensure the proper treatment of individuals in custody.

The inquiry made several recommendations to address the issues identified. These included implementing stricter protocols for the treatment of detainees, improving training for police officers on appropriate conduct and use of force, and enhancing oversight mechanisms to ensure accountability within the police force. The inquiry also emphasized the importance of protecting the rights and dignity of individuals in custody.

The tribunal's findings and recommendations aimed to restore public confidence in the police force and ensure that incidents of misconduct were appropriately addressed. The inquiry lasted approximately 14 months, concluding in April 1959. The cost of the inquiry was not specified in the sources available.

In summary, the Tribunal of Inquiry into the Alleged Assault on John Waters was a significant effort to investigate serious allegations of police misconduct, uncover the truth, and recommend measures to prevent similar incidents in the future. The tribunal's work highlighted the need for improved police practices and accountability to protect the rights of individuals in custody.